NEW DELHI: Supreme Court‘s registry came under an unflattering spotlight Friday with a bench led by the CJI smelling a rat in Enforcement Directorate‘s appeal challenging grant of bail to an accused in a money laundering case not getting listed for three years. It ordered SC’s top administrative officer to conduct a thorough inquiry into the reasons behind the registry consigning a live case to cold storage.Finding that ED’s appeal against bail to Raman Singhal was last listed in Sept 2023, when the court had issued notice to the accused, a bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana said, “What is that great magic wand that was used by someone by which the case was not listed for hearing for three years?”
Join conversation
Share your thoughts in the comments
Be respectful · TOI community guidelines
It added, “It was directed to be listed in Sept 2023. Sept 2024, Sept 2025 and Sept 2026 have gone by and the matter did not get listed. Who managed it? The registry must explain this lapse.” Senior advocate Sidharth Dave said no one could manage listing in SC as it was computer-based but the bench said, “What other inference can we draw from the non-listing?”The bench directed secretary general Ajit Atri to carry out an inquiry and file a report explaining why ED’s petition was not listed.“It seems that the listing branch (of the registry) would have continued to not list the appeal but for our Nov 4 order,” the bench said.Though the court ordered an inquiry into the non-listing of the matter, it disposed of the appeal and said it would not entertain a challenge to bail granted more than three years ago, especially after ED counsel Zoheb Hossain informed SC that the trial in the case had already commenced and eight witnesses had been examined.
